Home

Previous Entry | Next Entry

The Humble Reader (and Writer)

  • Oct. 24th, 2007 at 9:45 AM
jacket, superzero
So anyway,
I was following this thread on the Blue Boards, and thought of this thought-provoking (my thoughts, anyway) passage exploring the concepts of ethical judgment of fiction, the 'submissive' reader, the give and take between author and reader, and the humble creativity of both reading and writing (incidentally, it also refers to J. K. Rowling):


"...learning the contours of a fictional world or the intricacies of an author's methods always takes time. Robert Penn Warren commented that the most 'intuitive and immediate' reading of a poem will likely not come at a first reading, but rather at the tenth or even the fiftieth reading. To grasp the whole, one must, he speculated, be able not only to remember the beginning of the poem, but remember its end; one must be able to 'remember forward.' Patience, in short, is an essential quality of a good reader, and this too is an act of humility...


Harry Potter creator JK Rowling has been quoted all over the Internet as saying that she is happy that her books have produced a surge in children's involvement in Satanism. This quotation has been used as evidence that the Potter books are infernal propaganda. The original source of the quotation, however, was a story from a satirical electronic magazine. For anyone who took a moment to check the original source, and took another moment to ask about the tone of the article, it was clear that the author was mocking hysterical responses to Rowling's books. It must be a delicious irony to the article's author that the satire has become fuel for even more hysteria.


Though they may be harsh opponents of postmodernism, readers who took that Rowling quote at face value are as domineering and prideful in their reading practices as any deconstructionist. But how was one to know that the Rowling quotation was a fake? The text did not come with a label "Satire." The author expected the readers to recognize the clues and read in submission to them. Quick and ignorant judgments such as these are not only an embarrassment that often makes Christians, quite rightly, objects of ridicule. Far worse, the misreadings signal an appalling lack of Christian character. Patience before the text is not merely a readerly virtue. It is a fruit of the Spirit."


from "Authors, Authority, and The Humble Reader by Peter J. Leithart (The Christian Imagination, edited by Leland Ryken)


Also...Color Online is looking for submissions:

Color Online wants to know what you're reading. Send us a short review of a book or collection of poetry. Reviews can be as short as 200 words no more than 500. If we use your review, we'll send you a free book! We're looking for reviews on books by women of color. Our target audience is young women between 14-21 or anyone who reads YA and women's literature. If you have questions, write us at cora_litgroup@yahoo.com.

Comments

[info]lilrongal wrote:
Oct. 24th, 2007 02:18 pm (UTC)
There's no link, but a huge strikethrough your whole post! :(
[info]olugbemisola wrote:
Oct. 24th, 2007 02:47 pm (UTC)
yikes -- thank you!
[info]elva_undine wrote:
Oct. 24th, 2007 06:18 pm (UTC)
How strange...wouldn't your *first* response be that, if not that the quote came from a satire, that she was joking? I guess that's just those of us who realize there is more to Christianity than persecuting without thought.
Thanks for bringing this up though, I hadn't heard this supposed quotation.
[info]breckinwood wrote:
Oct. 24th, 2007 07:34 pm (UTC)
That "quote" was from 5 or 6 years ago. It was all pretty silly. Some people from my in-law's church got so upset by it that they attended book "burnings." (they couldn't get fire permits for public places, so they cut up the books with scissors.)
I happily bought my latest copy of HP and devoured it amidst the storm of protest.
[info]olugbemisola wrote:
Oct. 25th, 2007 05:20 pm (UTC)
Yeah, I remember that my first assumption back then was of course she's being sarcastic, and I was really surprised by friends who had the instant AHA! reaction....Anyway, I hadn't thought of this idea of being 'patient before a text', and it's an interesting one, I think. Makes me think of my reactions to the same books at different times in my life, and of how my opinions on the HP series changed over time, especially with the last book. All fun to chew on...